Non-Commutative Music

By

On Non-Commutative Homometric Musical Structures

AI on Non-Commutative Music

"Non-commutative music" refers to the application of mathematical non-commutativity—where the order of operations matters, i.e., \(A + B \neq B + A\)—to musical structures. In music theory, this concept is primarily associated with Generalized Interval Systems (GIS) pioneered by music theorist David Lewin, and spectral geometries developed by mathematician Alain Connes. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
The Concept
In traditional math and music, the order of certain operations doesn't matter. For example, moving up an octave then up a perfect fifth yields the same pitch class as moving up a perfect fifth then up an octave.
However, when analyzing more complex, relativistic relationships—such as overlapping rhythmic time-spans, complex voice-leading, or the specific permutation of pitch sets—the order in which intervals or transformations are applied changes the final musical result. Applying operation \(A\) then \(B\) is completely different from applying \(B\) then \(A\). [1, 2, 3]
Applications & Theory
  • Generalized Interval Systems (GIS): Pioneered by David Lewin, this framework allows theorists to model musical events (such as time-spans or chords) where standard commutative metrics don't apply.
  • Mathematics & Physics: Fields Medalist Alain Connes utilizes non-commutative geometry to link the underlying physics of quantum mechanics to Pythagorean tuning, effectively exploring the "music of shapes" at a quantum level. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
If you are exploring the crossover of advanced mathematics, geometry, and experimental sound, you can look into the theoretical writings in Oxford Academic's Generalized Interval Systems or explore papers like HAL Open Science on Non-Commutative Homometry which map the distances between musical chords and interval sequences.
Local Note: If you want to experience the modern, avant-garde side of these complex mathematical concepts live in the Arlington/Fort Worth area, check out the Sounds Modern Event Calendar at the Modern Art Museum of Fort Worth, which regularly curates programs featuring experimental music designed for deep thinkers.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Computing and the Linguistic Turn

By
Image
Enigma (Wikipedia) Symbolic analysis and statistical analysis were both approaches codebreakers took in breaking Enigma. The development of AI has also incorporated both approaches. One historical question for AI is why the dominance of Symbolic AI, associated here with the linguistic turn, from 1950 to 1990? Note the development of AI out of the Dartmouth Workshop and especially the contributions of one of its attendees,  Ray Solomonoff , to the statistical approach, an approach taken up by Marcus Hutter , a DeepMind  researcher, and of course, others. Note that a history of AI outside the linguistic turn from Moritz Hardt and Ben Recht is in Patterns, Predictions, and Actions . And note too that along with the difference between the symbolic and the statistical is the difference between language learning and computer vision, which tends to be a history outside the linguistic turn. And the turn Richard Sutton takes is to push learning outside the context of language, which ...
Read more

A Heidegger - Bayes Hybrid Model

By
Image
A Conjecture for a Hybrid Model Bayesian epistemology concerns modelling and specifically, belief, but a Bayesian belief does not need to be fully formed to emerge alongside the Heideggerian to-hand. The Heideggerian to-hand thereby becomes the interaction that generates this further, which is, with this interaction, a certain realization of being in the world. Bayesian selection now concerns available beliefs as well as any to-hand [belief(s)]. How Heidegger Can Make You a Better Guitarist Bayesian Philosophy Bayesian Philosophy Bayesian Epistemology Bayesian Epistemology Bayesian Modelling Bayesian Modelling Bayesian Model Selection David Deutsch on Bayesian Epistemology Bayesian Philosophy of Science Bayesian Philosophy of Science A Bayesian Approach to the Philosophy of Science On Sean Carroll on an Application of Bayes The Heideggerian To-Hand On Heidegger On Heidegger Flipping Descartes Ready-to-Hand and Present-at-Hand Presence-at-Hand Ready-to-Hand and Unready-to-Hand Does Hei...
Read more

A Question Regarding Number as the Assumed Basis of Mathematics

By
Conjecture: The historical analysis of the development of mathematics tends to lean on artifacts such as tally sticks and etch marks. Here, commerce serves as the basis of mathematics, and thereby, mathematics is grounded in the ability to count, which is implicitly understood to be the basis of commerce (fair exchange).  Development of Mathematics Question: What if distance becomes the basis of mathematics? How does this concept ground mathematics? Rather than assert that mathematics starts with counting, we assert instead that mathematics begins with the realization of distance? Do we then realize that number becomes a shorthand for distance in the abstract? Number Number ... Distance
Read more